When to Invest in a Pair of Climbing Shoes

So, you’ve started your climbing journey—congratulations! Climbing can quickly become a favorite way to stay active, challenge yourself, and connect with a community. But once you look at the wall of climbing shoes at your local gym, all the styles, shapes, and prices can feel intimidating.

Rental shoes are a good way to get started. At some point, though, you may wonder whether buying your own pair makes sense. This guide will help you decide when to invest, which questions to ask first, and which beginner-friendly shoes are worth considering.

When should you buy climbing shoes?

The right time depends on how often you climb, where you climb, and what you want from the sport. Here are three situations that may signal it’s time.

When rentals are costing more than a pair of shoes

A useful rule of thumb is to compare the cost of about 20 rental visits with the price of a pair of climbing shoes. The exact number depends on your gym’s rental rate and the shoes you are considering. If you expect to climb regularly, that comparison can show whether buying will save money over time.

Your rental frequency also tells you how much use your shoes will get. Climbing in the gym 20 times over a month or two suggests you’ll have plenty of opportunities to get value from a pair of your own.

During holiday sales

Many gyms offer Black Friday promotions or other holiday sales. Discounts may reach 20–30%, and some gyms offer an extra bonus when you purchase gift cards. Promotions vary from gym to gym, so check the terms before you plan around a sale. If you want to target a predictable sale period, late November is often a good time to look.

Before your first outdoor climbing trip

I recommend buying a pair before you start climbing outdoors. Some gyms and outdoor stores let you rent shoes for the crag, but gym rentals may not provide the same rubber performance you want on natural rock. A properly fitting pair can make the transition from the gym to the outdoors more comfortable and enjoyable.

For example, I took my first pair of climbing shoes—a pair of black La Sportiva Tarantulas—to top-rope in central Pennsylvania. They held up through the trip without forming holes, which gave me plenty of confidence in their durability.

Questions to ask before you invest in climbing shoes

As with any purchase, it helps to understand what you want from a new pair. Saving money on rentals is one practical goal. You may also want to improve your climbing, prepare for a competition, or commit to the sport for the long term.

Ask yourself:

1. Do I enjoy climbing enough to keep doing it?

2. Which grades feel easy for me right now?

3. Which grades are challenging?

4. Do I have competitions or climbing leagues in mind, or do I prefer casual training?

5. What is my budget?

There’s no benefit in buying shoes you dislike or cannot use comfortably. These questions are meant to clarify your goals and give local gym staff useful context when they help you choose a pair.

For example, if you’re still deciding whether climbing is for you but rental fees are adding up, consider looking for a gently used pair instead of buying brand-new shoes. If you know the grades you’re climbing in rentals, staff may point you toward a more intermediate model. Someone climbing around V3–V5 or 5.10–5.11, for instance, may be ready to explore shoes that offer more performance while still supporting a range of climbs.

Likewise, if you’re preparing for a competition or a friendly climbing league, a higher-end beginner shoe or an intermediate model may be a good fit. The best choice depends on your goals, budget, and the pace you want to take. Climbing is meant to be enjoyed, so choose equipment that supports that experience.

Which beginner climbing shoes should you consider?

There are many climbing shoes on the market, so narrowing down the options can feel overwhelming. Fit should always be your first priority, but these are two beginner-friendly models I often recommend.

La Sportiva Tarantula

The La Sportiva Tarantula is one of my go-to recommendations for new climbers. It typically costs around $115–$120, depending on your location and taxes, and it has a reputation for being durable.

The shoe’s stiffness can feel supportive while you learn different types of climbing, including slab climbing, standing on volumes, and climbing in caves. I know climbers who have used their Tarantulas for more than a year before holes formed in the soles. For a beginner looking for a durable first pair, they are an excellent option to try.

Tenaya Tanta

I also recommend the Tenaya Tanta. It typically costs around $120–$130, depending on your location and taxes, and can be a good option for climbers who need a narrower fit around the ankle and heel.

The Tanta is durable and supportive, making it a practical choice for beginners who want to explore different terrain and climbing styles. Try it alongside other models so you can compare how the shape feels on your foot.

Your First Pair

Buying your first pair of climbing shoes is a meaningful investment, but it doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Consider how often you climb, what you want to accomplish, how much you can spend, and whether you’re preparing to climb outdoors.

Whenever possible, try shoes on and test them on a few climbs before you buy. Talk with gym staff, pay attention to how the fit feels, and choose a pair that supports your goals. The right first pair can help you climb more comfortably—and enjoy the sport even more.